
First of all, you can download the entire album here.
Of all the artists that dominated the 60s and 70s, Neil Young is arguably the only one that has managed to remain relevant throughout nearly his entire career. Perhaps not popular, but never treading water. A lot of his albums from the 80s and 90s are average at best, but he's always had a knack for maintaining a sense of artistic integrity that eludes peers like Bob Dylan (Victoria's Secret, anyone?). Some of his latter-day triumphs like Freedom, Ragged Glory, and Greendale deserve to be spoken of in the same sentence as the best of his 70s work.
For the last, oh, thirty or so years, he has bounced back and forth between using 1972's Harvest and 1975's Tonight's the Night as jumping off points for his next musical tangent. I don't necessarily mean in terms of style, although the albums that recall Harvest are numerous, but in terms of attitude. There's Neil the elder country statesman, and there's Neil the crotchety, eccentric old man. And let's face it, he's always seemed kind of old, even when rocking the fuck out with Crazy Horse.
I'm sure this exercise in Neilology has been done many times before, but the take-home point is that he's still awesome, and he has two modes of awesome. Last year's Prairie Wind was the work of "Harvest Neil". It was sufficiently affable, but I think we can all agree that "Tonight's the Night Neil" is the Neil of legend, and for every Harvest Moon, I expect a Greendale.
I just never expected one so soon.
Less than a year after Prairie Wind, he announces this album, Living With War, a protest album about President Bush, the war in Iraq, and the state of America. Needless to say, many were skeptical. Although when I heard it described as "a brilliant electric assault", I must admit that my fears were at least partially assuaged. The feverish pace of it all was also a reason for optimism. The album was made available to steam over the internet yesterday, but it was recorded just weeks ago. Clearly Neil had a message that he considered urgent, and even if we all knew what it was going to be, it was refreshing to see him so energized after coming off as so erudite on Prairie Wind and its companion film Heart of Gold.
And now that I've lived with the album for a good 36 hours and 10+ listens, I can tell you that it surpasses any conceivable expectations. It's great, it's the best album he's made since Tonight's the Night, it's likely to be the best album of 2006, and it ought to be a clarion call for America to wake up and stop embracing the Team America approach to evaluating political activism. Living With War is a masterpiece.
As a self-proclaimed Neil Young obsessive, I reached that conclusion right about when the drums on "After the Garden" kick in. The track is reminiscent of "Country Home", the first track of Ragged Glory; a craggy rocker with a soaring, sublime melody. He makes his intentions clear with the first line: "Don't need no shadow man runnin' the government". The rest of the lyrics are more ambiguous, but the song is nothing if not upbeat. This is exactly the song that I've been wanting to hear from Neil for years.
The choir that was just barely audible in "After the Garden" is more prominent on the reflective, gorgeous title track. Throughout the album, the use of the choir is always tasteful, and it always adds to the song. In fact, it's one of the things that really propels to Living With War to great heights. Neil's idiosyncratic use of the choir is charming on "The Restless Consumer", where the choir dominates the verses, only to disappear as Neil's voice cracks (as only his can) and dies in the first chorus.
The propulsive "Shock and Awe" co-opts the Bush Administration's slogan in the album's most angry track. He decries the tragedy of the war. We all know the story, but what's striking about this song (apart from how perfectly it brings the rock) is how he avoids placing direct blame for the war, instead approaching it as a tragedy. He doesn't overlook the key observation that there was a clear majority of Americans who supported the war, and it is not just Bush's mess, but our mess.
And that insight is the key to the albums success. It deftly avoids sinking into partisan cheese by presenting a vision of America that is shameful, but entirely optimistic. It doesn't appeal to a hatred of President Bush, it appeals to a love for America and what our nation stands for. He appeals to the strength of the American family on "Families", one of the most moving tracks on the album, despite its brevity. Instead of dwelling on how bad our situation is, he tries to remind of us how much better we could make it.
And, you know, that's that one song that everyone's dying to hear, the ostentatiously titled "Let's Impeach the President". When the lyrics first appeared a couple weeks ago, reactions ranged from "Holy shit, this is bad" to "Well, they might sound better than they read". Here's a snippet:
Let's impeach the president for lying
And leading our country into war
Abusing all the power that we gave him
And shipping all our money out the door
You see what I mean? I think Neil fans everywhere let out a sigh of relief when they discovered that the song is, in fact, utterly amazing. It's as anthemic as anything Neil has ever written, and the man has written some anthems. It's angry, it's uplifting, it's unifying, and it's actually kind of hilarious. Midway through the song he juxtaposes soundbytes of President Bush contradicting himself with Neil yelping "FLIP…….FLOP" in his best angry grandpa voice. It couldn't be more effective. I suppose it's too much to ask that this song might be a hit single or something, but I won't give up hope.
The elegiac "Roger and Me" is an achingly beautiful story of a man losing his childhood friend to war. It's as good of a song as he's ever written. I'm hesitant to call it the highlight of the album, because every song is absolutely flawless, but I haven't been so moved by a song in a long time.
Roger and out, good buddy
I feel you in the air today
I know you gave for your country
I feel you in the air today
Simple lyrics, but drenched in that mournful, highway-at-sunset distortion that Neil practically invented, they are crushing. And to follow it up with a rousing rendition of "America the Beautiful" is a masterstroke.
I can honestly say that this is the most moving album I have ever heard. I've never heard music that appealed to my patriotism so genuinely. Lately I've felt a deep sense of despair at the direction the country is headed, but with one fell swoop, Neil Young has turned it around and made me proud to be an American (let's not get into the perversion that arises when you consider that Neil is Canadian by birth). He's going to be denounced by the right-wing and blasted as being un-American, and that's a crime. Living With War is the Great American Album.
Update: Download link updated